Grandbar to "clean up" its act by October 4 or...
The Tuesday morning deleterious impact hearing for Grandbar, formerly Betty's Blue Star Lounge, 1600 W. Grand Ave., ended with bar owner Gene Stokes having until Oct. 4 to make major changes in their business operations or face the possibility of losing their liquor license, according to Senior Attorney Vera Elue, Chicago Department of Business Affairs and Consumer Protection (BACP).
With many of the same people seated around the table as were there a year ago, Elue announced that BACP had worked with the bar on a plan of operation that addresses all of the issues. The only reason that it had not been signed off by the Liquor Commissioner was that he wasn't available.
Alderman Proco "Joe" Moreno, 1st Ward, and Andy Perdue, who represented the Chicago Grand Neighbors Association (CGNA), said that neither had seen the latest version of the plan and expressed that there had been an uptick in issues related to the bar in the last three weeks.
Chicago Police Commander Edward Kulbida, 12th District, said that in the last three weeks, things have gotten worse. He and 12th District Sergeant Rebecca Arguelles listed a series of incidents and calls for service that went back to June and were as current as August 20.
Patrick Sullivan, Grand Ave. resident, pointed out that everything was quiet after the last hearing for about six to eight weeks. "For the last three weeks, things are back to normal. Weren't we supposed to have this meeting on Aug. 9? I am just wondering if since they thought this meeting would have been on the ninth that they didn't just schedule to go back to their regular ways."
Everyone spoke to the fact that they felt that the kind of clientele that have been showing up are different and not people you want around an establishment.
The Commander pointed out that the clientele are determined by the DJ and their playlist. He also pointed out that they were supposed to send that list to the Commander after the last hearing. Stokes assured him that he would get it to him.
The behavior residents objected to include: trash/garbage in the street and on the sidewalks; loud talking/screaming or playing music in cars late night /early morning; public urination; intoxication; pre- and post-loading (drink in or around cars before/after being in the bar);violence; and one case of drug sales.
Looking at the records, Elue said that after all the interaction with Grandbar, all of the issues being brought up should have been resolved with everyone being happy and successful. [Grandbar had an unprecedented five hearings that ended about a year ago. Tuesday's was the third in the current series of hearings.] Clearly a successful resolution has not occurred.
Security
With an occupancy of 249, which Stokes said they have not experienced in a long time, Elue said that that is a reason to be very concerned about security about a bar that has had a 4 a.m. license for 40 years.
She asked about how many people they have filling those jobs. Stokes said six.
Residents pointed out that their security was parked within a couple of feet of where a May shooting occurred and that their security is present outside when the bar closes. However, they said, that does not appear to change the behavior of the crowd.
One security guard was caught sleeping in his vehicle parked along Marshfield. Elue asked if that person was still employed by the bar. Stokes said, "No and in fact we are trying to replace another guard who just quit."
Bill Jansen, Grandbar security, said that it is very difficult to find people to work and that while there is no security car on Marshfield, he stands at Marshfield and Grand. "I can look all the way down both streets."
"You need better and maybe more security. If you are using your relatives, fire them. Get trained, certified security. You should have people who look like people that command respect," said Elue.
Residents' Comments
Residents made a point of saying that they do not want to shutdown Grandbar and they believe that if the bar did not have a 4 a.m. liquor license, most of the problems would be eliminated.
Perdue explained that CGNA and Moreno had worked together to establish a community development plan for the Grand Ave. corridor and that the increased number of residential buildings was part of the plan.
With the increase of residential units," said Runa Howard, a Grand Ave. resident, "Grandbar could bring in more local business if they would add food service. I would go there and I am sure my neighbors would."
Residents have been saying that to Stokes since the first series of hearings. And, once again, Stokes says that it is expensive to put in a kitchen.
Hearing Results
Moreno and Elue met outside the meeting room. The alderman returned and said the Elue was meeting with the legal department. When she returned, she pointed out that they have a lot of material that they could use if they chose to revoke their liquor license.
However, she believes that they can be successful. Then she asked Stokes if he wants to be successful. He said, "Yes." She countered with, "Will you do this?" "Yes," he said, "I can try to do some things differently."
"You need to do everything you can to turn this around by Oct. 4. Hire more qualified security; talk with the Commander about DJs; cut your hours to 2 a.m.; and whatever else you can do that will have the neighbors, alderman and police saying that everything is good," encouraged Elue.
After the hearing, residents said that they were hopeful but skeptical about what will really be done. Since Grandbar's liquor license is up for renewal in November, they want to make sure operations are cleaned up before the renewal comes up.
Rocio Varela, Moreno's liaison with the police department, is the contact for concerns in the 1st Ward.
Background
This current series of hearings began on March 15 as a result of a Techno Breakfast, Grandbar was running from 7 to 11 a.m. Perdue described the re-occurring situation, "Groups of drunken people who live outside the neighborhood would leave the bar drunk then congregate on the sidewalk outside along Grand and Ashland.
Grandbar did cease holding those events.
